Who Is Responsible When Your Package Is Stolen?

Home Security   ·   Package Theft

Liability is not one answer. It depends on what the tracking shows and where the package was when it disappeared. Here is how it generally breaks down, and where to start your claim.

The Direct Answer

When a package is stolen, the general rule is that the seller or retailer is responsible until delivery is confirmed, then the question shifts to the carrier and, in some cases, your own homeowner's coverage. Who pays depends on what the tracking shows and the carrier's terms. Start your claim with whoever sold you the item.

Who's responsible, by scenario

Liability is not one answer. It depends on what the tracking says and where the package was when it disappeared. Here is how it generally breaks down. Find your situation, then act on the column that applies.

In plain terms: the retailer owns the order until the package is genuinely in your hands. A "delivered" scan is not the same as a package you actually received, and a good claim starts by saying exactly that.

How to file a claim for a stolen package

Once you know who is responsible, the claim itself is straightforward. The details vary by company, so confirm the current process on each one's official page before you start.

• Amazon: if the item was sold and shipped by Amazon (including Prime), start in Your Orders with "where's my package" or report a problem, or contact Amazon customer service. For a third-party marketplace order the seller will not resolve, file an A-to-z Guarantee claim.
• UPS: file a claim through the UPS claims process for a lost or damaged shipment. Note that the shipper typically files, and claims are time-limited (generally within 60 days).
• FedEx: open a claim through FedEx for a missing or damaged delivery.
• USPS: start with the missing-mail search, and report theft to the U.S. Postal Inspection Service.

Before you file, gather three things: the order or tracking number, the delivery scan or date, and any evidence the package did not arrive. Most claims move faster when you can show the gap between "marked delivered" and "never received."

Just had a package stolen? Here is what to do, step by step.

Our recovery guide walks the first hour: documenting it, reporting it, and getting your money back fast. Read the package-theft recovery steps →

When you're covered, and when you're not

A few situations decide most disputes:

• You're usually made whole when a package is never delivered, when the carrier delivers to the wrong address through its own error, or when a carrier mis-scans. These are the retailer's or carrier's responsibility and typically get reshipped or refunded. The seller carries the order until delivery is confirmed.
• It gets murkier when a package is confirmed delivered to the right address and then taken from the porch. That is theft, and responsibility generally falls to you, a police report and your own homeowner's or renter's insurance, depending on the value and your policy. Once a package is confirmed delivered to the correct address, retailers and carriers generally will not reship or refund a porch theft.
• You may not be covered when an item is left per your own delivery instructions (for example, "leave at side door") and is taken from there, or when a claim window has closed. Filing promptly matters.

The honest takeaway: most legitimate "it never arrived" claims are resolved in the buyer's favor, but porch theft after a confirmed delivery is the gray zone. That gray zone is exactly what a secure drop-off removes.

Free shipping on every order  ·  30-day returns  ·  Warranty  ·  Designed in Chicago  ·  Ships domestically

Prevention

How to stop this from happening again

Filing a claim gets you your money back when you are covered. It does not get you your afternoon back, and it does not stop the next package from sitting exposed on the porch. If you would rather not deal with the claim process again, the prevention move is simple: give deliveries a place to land that locks.

That is what the Adoorn Package Box is for. A carrier drops the box or parcel through the lid, it locks on close, and only you open it with the key. It is built from heavy-duty galvanized steel construction with stainless steel hinges and a rust-resistant powder-coat finish, weatherproof and worry-proof, and it anchors to the porch or driveway so the box itself cannot walk off. Backed by 350,000+ Adoorn installs and a 4.5-star Package Box rating.

Adoorn's policy, plainly: If an Adoorn order never arrives or the carrier delivers it to the wrong address, we reship at no cost. But like any retailer, we cannot cover a package stolen after it is confirmed delivered to your door. That is the gap a locking box closes.

Stop Dealing With Claims. See The Package Box →

Frequently asked

This article explains general retailer and carrier policies for informational purposes. Policies vary by company, plan, and circumstance and change over time. This is not legal advice. For your specific situation, check the carrier's or retailer's current policy and, if needed, consult a qualified professional.

Adoorn · the modern mailbox brand designed in Chicago.